What it looks like at home
Withholding rent usually starts after a repair problem drags on: damp spreading behind furniture, a boiler that keeps cutting out, a leaking roof, or an electrical fault that makes sockets unsafe. In many UK households, the pattern is similar. The tenant reports the issue, gets a few vague promises, and then receives a rent reminder or a warning about arrears. The temptation is to stop paying until the landlord acts.
In practice, withholding rent rarely produces the quick fix people hope for. Letting agents often treat it as a straightforward arrears case, even where the underlying complaint is genuine. Once rent is unpaid, the conversation can shift away from repairs and towards debt recovery, late-payment charges (where allowed), and threats of court action.
Some tenants also withhold rent because they believe the landlord has breached the agreement, or because they have paid for a repair themselves and want to “deduct it from rent”. That approach can work only in narrow circumstances and only when handled carefully with evidence and proper notice.
When withholding rent is allowed
In England and Wales, rent is still due even if the property has problems, unless a court orders otherwise or there is a clear legal basis to set-off costs. The safest position is that rent should be paid, while repairs are pursued through the correct channels.
There is one situation that sometimes works in real cases: paying for an urgent repair that the landlord is responsible for, then seeking reimbursement or deducting the cost from rent. Even then, it is not a free choice to stop paying. It needs a paper trail showing the landlord was given a reasonable chance to act, that the work was necessary, and that the cost was reasonable.
Another limited route is where a tenant has a genuine counterclaim for disrepair that can be set against rent arrears. That is usually argued during a possession claim, not used as a DIY reason to stop paying. It is risky because the landlord may still pursue eviction, and the tenant must prove the disrepair and the impact.
Common reasons people do it
Wait for repairs
The most common trigger is a repair that affects daily living: no heating or hot water, persistent leaks, mould, or pests. Tenants often feel the landlord is ignoring them, especially if messages go unanswered or contractors fail to attend.
Dispute a charge
Some withhold rent to challenge fees or deductions. In the UK, many charges are restricted, and disputes should be handled separately from rent payments. If the dispute is about add-on charges, it is usually safer to keep rent paid and challenge the charge with evidence. See Tenant fees charged illegally for common examples and what typically works.
Replace a broken item
Another common scenario is a broken appliance. Tenants sometimes buy a replacement and then reduce rent to “cover it”. Whether the landlord must repair or replace depends on what was provided and what the tenancy says. A clearer route is to agree reimbursement in writing first. If the issue is an appliance supplied with the property, check Broken appliances — who pays? before spending money.
React to a rent rise
Withholding rent is sometimes used to push back against a rent increase. That can backfire if the increase is valid and the tenant simply stops paying the new amount. If a rent rise is disputed, it is usually better to challenge it through the correct process and keep paying the undisputed rent. For the usual UK routes, see Rent increase — is it legal in the UK?.
Safer steps before stopping payment
Log the problem
Collect evidence early. Photos and short videos with dates help, especially for leaks, mould, broken heating controls, or unsafe electrics. Keep a simple timeline: when it was reported, who was contacted, and what response was received.
Report in writing
Send the repair report by email or letter, not only by phone or text. Include what is wrong, when it started, and how it affects the home (for example, “no hot water since Monday” or “bedroom wall damp and mould spreading”). Ask for a proposed date for inspection and repair.
Allow reasonable time
What counts as “reasonable” depends on urgency. No heating in winter, a serious leak, or an electrical hazard should be treated as urgent. Cosmetic issues or minor defects may take longer. In many UK cases, the turning point is when the tenant can show repeated requests over a sensible period with no action.
Chase with a deadline
If there is no response, send a follow-up giving a clear deadline for a contractor visit. Keep the tone factual. Mention that the local council’s environmental health team may be contacted if the issue is not addressed.
Use the council route
Where conditions are poor or unsafe, local councils can inspect and may serve notices requiring work. This often gets faster results than withholding rent, because it creates an official record and deadlines. It also helps later if the landlord disputes the severity of the problem.
How to deduct repair costs
Deducting the cost of repairs from rent is sometimes called “repair and deduct”. It is not automatic, and it is easiest to defend when the repair is clearly the landlord’s responsibility and the tenant has followed a careful process.
Confirm landlord responsibility
Check the tenancy agreement and the nature of the fault. Structural issues, plumbing, heating systems, and electrics are commonly the landlord’s responsibility. Damage caused by misuse is usually not.
Give a final warning
Send a written notice stating that if the repair is not completed by a specific date, a contractor will be instructed and the cost will be requested back or deducted from rent. This should not be used for non-urgent improvements.
Get competitive quotes
Obtain at least two quotes where possible. Choose a reasonable price, not the fastest premium option, unless it is an emergency. Keep the quotes and the decision reason.
Use a proper invoice
Pay a legitimate contractor and keep the invoice and proof of payment. Cash-in-hand without paperwork is hard to rely on if challenged.
Notify before deducting
Send the invoice to the landlord or agent and request reimbursement. If deducting from rent, state the exact amount and attach the evidence. Pay the remaining rent on time. Partial payment without explanation often gets treated as arrears.
What happens if it’s ignored
Rent arrears can escalate quickly. Agents may issue formal arrears letters, add permitted interest, and report missed payments. If arrears build up, a landlord may start possession proceedings. Even where disrepair is real, the tenant can end up defending an eviction claim while also trying to prove the repair issues.
Another common outcome is that communication breaks down. Contractors stop being booked, the landlord becomes less cooperative, and the tenant’s bargaining position weakens. If a deposit dispute follows, unpaid rent is often the first deduction claimed.
Where the property is genuinely unsafe, withholding rent also does not fix the hazard. Damp, mould, and electrical faults tend to worsen, and health impacts (especially for children or asthma sufferers) become harder to ignore.
When to escalate properly
Seek early advice
If there is a risk of arrears or eviction, get advice before changing payment behaviour. Evidence-based advice can prevent a small dispute turning into a possession claim. Citizens Advice is a practical starting point for tenancy rights and next steps.
Use formal complaints
If there is a letting agent, use their complaints process in writing. Ask for the property manager’s name, the repair reference number, and contractor attendance dates. Keep copies of everything.
Contact the council
For serious disrepair, contact the local council’s private renting or environmental health team. An inspection report or notice often becomes the key evidence if the landlord later disputes the condition.
Prepare for legal action
If the landlord threatens court, gather a clean evidence pack: tenancy agreement, rent statement, all repair reports, photos/videos, contractor no-show messages, medical letters if relevant, and any council correspondence. For official information and routes, use GOV.UK guidance.
Evidence that usually helps
Keep a rent trail
Bank statements, standing order confirmations, and a rent schedule showing dates and amounts help show good faith. If any deduction is made, the written explanation should match the payment date.
Show repair history
Emails, letters, screenshots of messages, and call logs help demonstrate repeated reporting. Photos should show scale and location (for example, include a radiator, window, or corner to orient the image).
Record contractor outcomes
Note missed appointments, partial fixes, and repeat failures. In many disputes, the landlord argues that access was refused; a clear log of offered dates and attendance helps rebut that.
FAQ
Can rent be withheld for mould?
Rent is still due in most cases. Mould should be reported in writing with photos, and the council route is often more effective than withholding payment.
Is it legal to pay half…
Partial payment without agreement can create rent arrears. If deducting for a specific repair, the amount and evidence should be set out in writing and the remainder paid on time.
What if the landlord won’t respond?
Escalate in writing, set deadlines, and contact the local council for inspection where conditions are poor or unsafe. Keep paying rent unless advised otherwise.
Can a tenant be evicted for…
Arrears can be used as grounds for possession. Disrepair may form a defence or counterclaim, but it needs strong evidence and does not guarantee the case will be stopped.
Does withholding rent force repairs?
In many UK cases it slows progress, because the landlord focuses on arrears. Formal repair routes and council involvement tend to produce clearer outcomes.
Before you move on
Pull together a one-page timeline (dates, reports, responses), attach the best photos, and decide the next safe action: pay rent as normal while escalating repairs, or use a documented repair-and-deduct approach only where the responsibility and urgency are clear. If you felt pushed to act quickly or told there was no time, that’s often a sign the process wasn’t handled properly.
Get help with the next step
If rent arrears are building or repairs are being ignored, get the situation checked against the tenancy terms and the evidence so the next message or complaint lands properly. Use the contact form at https://ukfixguide.com/contact/.
2 thoughts on “Withholding rent — when it’s allowed”